The Role of Judges in Developing Future Judges

NASDA Judges play a critical role in the development of future judges. The quality, consistency, and integrity of our program depend not only on how current judges perform, but also on how effectively they mentor and guide those entering the program.

Apprentice judges rely on experienced judges to model appropriate decision-making, professionalism, and application of the rules. Your involvement directly shapes the next generation of NASDA judges and, ultimately, the future of the sport.

The Role of the Supervising Judge

Serving as a Supervising Judge requires more than evaluating dogs—it requires active teaching, leadership, and accountability.

Professionalism and Leadership

  • Maintain professionalism at all times
  • Demonstrate clear, consistent rule application
  • Model appropriate ring presence and communication

Your actions set the standard for how apprentice judges will conduct themselves in the future.

Active Engagement with Apprentice Judges

Supervising Judges are expected to actively involve apprentice judges throughout the event, including:

  • Hands-on participation in course building
  • Discussion and review of search area selection
  • Evaluation of hide placement and suitability
  • Real-time discussion of:
    • Environmental factors
    • Odor movement
    • Dog behavior and alert styles
    • Deductions and scoring decisions

Apprentices should not be passive observers—they should be engaged participants in the learning process.

Supporting Supervised Judging Assignments

When an apprentice is completing supervised judging, the Supervising Judge must:

  • Review and approve:
    • Course setups
    • Hide placements
  • Ensure setups are:
    • Appropriate for the level
    • Safe and consistent with NASDA standards
  • Compare scoring and decision-making
  • Provide clear, constructive feedback

Communication During the Trial

While education is important, the trial must remain efficient and professional.

  • Answer questions and provide guidance without delaying the trial
  • Keep discussions concise and relevant
  • Address more in-depth topics between classes or after the event when appropriate

Balancing education with trial flow is a key skill of an effective Supervising Judge.

Apprentice Evaluation and Feedback

Following the event, Supervising Judges are responsible for providing feedback on apprentice performance through the Judging Summary Form.

This review should include:

  • Strengths observed
  • Areas for improvement
  • Readiness for progression

This feedback is critical to ensuring the apprentice judge receives a well-rounded and consistent education.